On September 26th 1942, the 15,000
tons Blue Star liner Andalucia Star, commanded by Captain
James Bennett Hall, sailed from Buenos Aires for the United Kingdom by way
of Freetown. She carried the usual large cargo of refrigerated meat and
other foodstuffs, and had on board a crew of 170 and 83 passengers, mainly
British volunteers coming home to take part in the war, and including 22
women and three children. All went well until about 10:0 p.m. on the night
of October 6th when, steaming at her full speed of 16 knots
without lights, in a position about
180 miles south-west of
Freetown and within a few hundred miles of where the
Viking Star and
Tuscan Star had been sent to the bottom
on August 2nd and September 6th, the Andalucia
Star was torpedoed twice almost simultaneously abreast of Numbers 5
and 6 holds. Passengers and crew at once mustered at their boat stations,
and on discovering that the main engine-room was flooding fast and there was
no hope of saving the ship, Captain Hall gave the order for her to be
abandoned.
Without the least signs of panic, all the
boats were manned by their crews and passengers, lowered, and with one
exception got safely away. The exception was lifeboat Number 2, the forward
fall of which took charge during lowering, left her suspended by the after
fall, and precipitated most of the occupants and her gear into the sea. All
but two of her people, Mrs. L. A. Green, a stewardess, and a steward, were
rescued.
About 20 minutes after the first attack the
Andalucia Star was torpedoed a third time. The torpedo struck
on the port side abreast Number 1 hold, the detonation being so violent that
it blew out the starboard side of the ship also. Two boats filled with
people that were alongside the starboard side had providential escapes from
being destroyed; but were able to cast off and get clear.

Andalucia Star torpedoed for the third time ~
Painting
©
Wallace Trickett
Captain Hall was now left on board with four
men. As the sea round the bows was covered with oil fuel, the captain took
these four aft, where he hoped the water would be clearer. There he met a
passenger, who, for one reason or another, had not gone to his boat station
and seemed to be dazed. They managed to launch a raft and jumped overboard
after it. One member of the crew, who with great difficulty had to be helped
by the others, died of heart failure. The unfortunate passenger, though they
searched for him, was never seen again.
At about 10.25 p.m. the Andalucia Star
plunged to the bottom. No signs of the U-boat (
U-107 ) had been seen.
The people in the boats and raft were sorted
out, and Captain Hall decided they should remain together during the night.
Luckily the weather was good, with no more than a slight swell. No ships or
aircraft being in sight next morning, October 7th, the boats
hoisted their sails and proceeded for Freetown, about 18o miles to the
north-east. Keeping together, they sailed throughout that day with a fair
wind and an overcast sky with rain, until, in the early hours next morning,
they sighted, and were sighted by, the corvette H.M.S. Petunia.
By about 4:0 a.m. the occupants of all the boats had been safely picked up
and were landed at Freetown the same evening.
Captain Hall was a man of few words. His
report was terse and restrained, and mentioned little beyond the bare facts.
But at the end of his narrative he wrote:
“I would like to mention here that W. S.
wheeler, Lamptrimmer, dived into the water from his boat and rescued a
little girl passenger bringing her safely to the boat. Also N. Bennett, who
volunteered to take over the wheel in place of Williams who was a married
man. This request was granted and he was one of the last to leave the ship
with me.”
Captain Hall and Able Seaman Norman Bennett
were both officially “commended for their services when the Andalucia
Star was sunk, as was the Fourth Engineer, Mr. John Williams
Hubbard, for his promptitude and devotion to duty in stopping the engines
and remaining in the engine-room until ordered to leave. Mrs. L. A. Green,
Stewardess, also received a posthumous commendation, the Merchant Navy
equivalent of a “mention in despatches”. As already mentioned, Mrs. Green
lost her life during the lowering of one of the boats. She had previously
shown coolness, for and devotion to duty in caring for the women and
children passengers. One of her last acts was to switch on the red waistcoat
light of a little girl aged four-and-a-half, and it was this light burning
that enabled the child to be found and saved after she had been thrown into
the water. When the child was the water she was seen for a moment by a
fellow passenger, but then drifted away.
For saving the life of this little girl
William Stewart Wheeler, the Lamptrimmer, was awarded the Bronze Medal for
Gallantry in Saving Life at Sea. I will quote the official citation from the
London Gazette:
“The ship, carrying a number of passengers
was torpedoed in the darkness. As the vessel was sinking rapid abandonment
was ordered. During the abandonment one of the boats was up-ended and in
occupants thrown into the sea. Other hosts which had got clear were picking
up survivors when the cry of a small child was heard some distance away.
Wheeler immediately dived into the water, swam through wreckage for a
distance of 600 yards to the child and supported it for over 30 minutes
until they were found by another hoar and picked up. Lamptrimmer Wheeler
displayed great courage in plunging overboard into a choppy sea covered with
wreckage. But for his gallant action the life of the child s would
undoubtedly have been lost.”